11.01.2009
My Case For: Rush

In the long history of rock and roll, there are the overrated bands (U2, the Allman Brothers Band) and the underrated bands (The Kinks, The Band). There are the classic bands (Beatles, Stones, Pink Floyd) and the niche bands (The Replacements, Fugazi).
Then there are the bands that divide us. Rush is one of those bands.
Detractors will say that Neil Peart’s lyrics are ridiculous, steeped in sci-fi and fantasy worlds. Well you know what? So were Robert Plant’s and Jimmy Page’s, and Led Zeppelin seemed to do alright for itself.
But put the lyrics aside and what you’re left with is a wall of sound by three of the hardest rocking men in history.
As far as musical trios go, the top five look something like this:
5. Cream
4. Big Star (okay maybe they’re a little light for “power” trio, but they kick ass)
3. Nirvana
2. The Jimi Hendrix Experience
1. Rush
Yes, Rush is higher than Hendrix, Cobain, and Clapton. And the reason is consistency. Nearly every Rush album is a great, layered piece of art.
Rush songs sound perfect, whether on a stereo or headphones. Peart is one of the greatest drummers of all time, and Geddy Lee bassline on “Spirit of Radio” is one of the most recognizable in all of music.
The band has 24 gold records, and 14 platinum ones, selling more than 40 million albums worldwide.
So why no respect? Number one, they’re Canadian. I usually hate Canadians (like most good Americans should) but I’ll put my hatred aside for Rush.
Number two? Well, there is no number two because you should love Rush.
And look at this! Jason Segal, from How I Met Your Mother and Forgetting Sarah Marshall, loves Rush! Well, at least his character in Freaks and Geeks does. Check it:
Oh and they somehow aren’t in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Just another reason why I hate that stupid place.

It doesn't get much better than Neil Peart in YYZ. The only other that maybe comes second is in Moby Dick by Led Zeppelin. In my own opinion.
ReplyDeleteNot to mention Jason Segal and Paul Rudd's fanaticism for Rush in I Love You, Man
ReplyDeleteI think what you meant was "Jason Segel, from 'I Love You Man,' loves Rush because he's obsessed with them in that movie too. Rush is pretty much the entire soundtrack.
ReplyDeleteend quote.
ReplyDeleteRush!
ReplyDeleteWow...Allman Brothers Overrated?!?! Outrageous
ReplyDeleteRush tears me in half, one half loves the music, the other wants to go deaf everytime it hears Geddy Lee's voice.
ReplyDeleteAllman brothers overrated? hardly. And I think you got your top 5 out of order too.
oh my god, this post was so overdue! rush is amazing. in 9th grade i told my dad i wanted to play the drums. after a lot of internet searching (which took some time because this was in 2000), he found a drum solo by peart himself and said i could only play if i thought i'd become that good.
ReplyDeleteneedless to say, i never played the drums.
on another note, when i wrote "i wanted to play the drums," i originally wrote "i wanted to play the drugs." which was probably true, but i would never have told my father that.
I don't listen to Rush. Canada sucks.
ReplyDelete